Stillwell v. State Farm Fire & Cas. Co., No. 21-13740 (11th Cir. May 27, 2026) (unpublished).
The Medicare Secondary Payer Act requires that a primary payer reimburse conditional payments made by Medicare. The determination of liability can be premised upon a settlement, judgment, or award. This right to recover conditional payments extends to Medicare Advantage Organizations. In Stillwell, however, the Eleventh Circuit held that the insurers had no obligation to reimburse Medicare for medical expenses incurred after a settlement that released them from future liability and placed responsibility for those expenses on the beneficiary.
In Stillwell, the plaintiff was injured in a slip-and-fall that ultimately led to the amputation of his leg. The Stillwells agreed to settle the matter, releasing the insurers from any further liability, including for future medical costs, in return for a lump sum payment. While the insurers proposed a formal agreement with these terms, the Stillwells refused to sign it as they believed that the insurers had an ongoing obligation to reimburse Medicare for post-settlement accident-related medical expenses. The insurers moved to enforce the terms of the agreement in the trial court, and the trial court granted the motion and entered judgment finding that the Stillwells were “jointly and severally liable for payment of any existing or future medical lien.”
Medicare’s pre-settlement conditional payments had already been reimbursed. Medicare nevertheless continued to pay for William Stillwell’s post-settlement medical expenses. Given this, Penelope Stillwell, individually and on behalf of William’s estate, filed a complaint in federal district court alleging, among others, claims under the Medicare Secondary Payer Act, arguing that the insurer was responsible for the post-settlement medical expenses. In support of this, Stillwell made four arguments.
- Stillwell argued that the settlement agreement shows that the insurers “had a responsibility” before the settlement to pay those expenses. However, according to the Eleventh Circuit, the insurer must have had a responsibility for payment at the time the payment was made by Medicare. Because the settlement agreement foreclosed the insurers’ responsibility for expenses incurred after settlement, they had no obligation to reimburse Medicare for those expenses.
- Stillwell argued that the settlement agreement cannot extinguish the insurer’s responsibility to reimburse Medicare for post-settlement accident-related medical expenses. In support of this proposition, Stillwell cited Hadden v. United States, 661 F.3d 298 (6th Cir. 2011) and Humana Med. Plan, Inc. v. W. Heritage Ins. Co., 832 F.3d 1229 (11th Cir. 2016), which addressed reimbursement of pre-settlement conditional payments. Hadden required the beneficiary to reimburse Medicare from settlement proceeds; Humana required the liability insurer to reimburse an MAO despite having paid the settlement to the beneficiary. The Eleventh Circuit disagreed, noting that these cases addressed pre-settlement medical expenses already conditionally paid by Medicare or an MAO, rather than expenses incurred after settlement.
- Stillwell also argued that because Medicare “‘will not . . . recognize[]’ a workers’-compensation settlement that fails to account for Medicare’s interest in not paying for future work-related medical expenses,” the same should be true in tort cases. The Eleventh Circuit declined to apply this analogy from a fundamentally different area of law. It also explained that, even if those regulations applied, they addressed Medicare’s refusal to pay for treatment, not an insurer’s obligation to reimburse post-settlement payments Medicare had already made.
- Finally, Stillwell argued that the no-fault insurance provisions demonstrated that the insurers had responsibility for repaying these expenses. The Eleventh Circuit concluded, however, that once the insurers paid the lump-sum settlement in exchange for a release of all claims—and reimbursed Medicare for William’s past medical expenses—they were no longer responsible for William’s post-settlement medical expenses under any provision of the liability insurance policies.
The decision is unpublished and therefore is only persuasive authority, not binding precedent. The court relied on the settlement’s release of future liability and the Indiana trial court’s judgment enforcing the settlement, including terms the Stillwells had refused to sign. Stillwell was not an MAO recovery action and did not directly decide an MAO’s responsibility for future treatment.
Still, for those seeking recovery for Medicare Advantage Plans, its reasoning highlights a potential obstacle: a liability insurer may invoke a settlement releasing future liability to resist reimbursement of an MAO’s payments for medical expenses incurred after settlement. That concern does not undermine recovery of pre-settlement conditional payments.





