Allstate Prop. & Cas. Ins. Co. v. Jarnigan, No. 2024-SC-0451-DG, 2026 Ky. LEXIS 199 (Oct. 22, 2026).
At its core, the made whole rule determines who stands first in line for a limited recovery. The injured party comes first; a subrogated party subject to the rule collects only after the injured party has been fully compensated. If the funds run out before that happens, the subrogated party goes unpaid.
The harder question is what happens when that order is reversed. If the liability insurer pays the subrogated party first, leaving insufficient funds to make the injured party whole, who must correct the mistake? Must the subrogated party return the payment, or must the liability insurer bear the loss? That is the question at the heart of this recent Kentucky Supreme Court decision.
Jarnigan was injured in a motor vehicle accident. Allstate paid basic reparation benefits (no-fault personal injury protection benefits available in Kentucky) of $10,000. Jarnigan and Allstate then both made claims against the liability carrier, State Farm. Despite Jarnigan’s claims still pending, State Farm paid $9,000 of Allstate’s $10,000 claim.
When Jarnigan went to settle his case, State Farm informed him that only $41,000 of the $50,000 policy limits remained, and the parties settled the case for $41,000. For the purposes of the motion, none of the parties disputed that Jarnigan was not made whole by the $41,000 settlement.
Kentucky statutes clearly lay out that the basic reparation benefits carrier’s claims are not repaid until the injured party is made whole,¹ but Allstate was permitted to keep the $9,000 paid to it by State Farm. The court held that it was State Farm’s responsibility to ensure that its primary obligation to the injured victim is paid first; “if it volunteers payment to the subrogated carrier before the resolution of the claim of the injured party, it cannot assert any right to reduce the available coverage for that injury by the amount of the payment, and it must absorb the loss caused by its folly.”²
In other words, it is clear that State Farm should not have paid Allstate first, but that was never really the dispute. The dispute was whether Allstate had a responsibility to give up the amount it had been reimbursed. While the majority decided that it did not, and that is now the rule in Kentucky, the decision was not without dissenters. One justice focused on Allstate’s responsibility to honor the injured party’s priority once it learned that retaining the payment interfered with their priority, while another would have allowed recovery under a theory of unjust enrichment.
This ability to keep improperly paid reimbursement is a state-specific rule that will differ across the country. If your state does not currently have any binding authority on this, do not assume that they will land one way or the other. The disagreement among the justices illustrates why the outcome should not be taken for granted elsewhere.
¹ KRS 304.39-070 and KRS 304.39-140(3).
² Allstate Prop. & Cas. Ins. Co. v. Jarnigan, No. 2024-SC-0451-DG, 2026 Ky. LEXIS 199, at *16 (Oct. 22, 2026), citing Jordan R. Plitt et al., 16 Couch on Ins. § 225:83 (2026).





