Goldman-Nagel v. Werntz, 2025AP137, 2026 WL 3168371 (Wis. Ct. App. Oct 22, 2026).
When a person is bitten by a dog, Wisconsin law provides for strict liability against the owner, harborer, or keeper of the dog. This means that the injured person does not need to prove negligence on behalf of the owner in order to recover.
This does not, however, mean that dog-bite cases are without legal issues. One of the most frequently litigated issues is whether a person owns, harbors, or keeps the dog. This was exactly the issue in the recent Wisconsin Court of Appeals case of Goldman-Nagel v. Werntz. In that case, Plaintiff was bitten by a dog in the hallway of a condominium building. She sued not only the owners of the dog—which was not a subject of dispute—but also the condo association, arguing that they were harborers of the dog.
The Court of Appeals disagreed. While “’harboring’ a dog means ‘sheltering or giving refuge to a dog,’” a condo association is not a harborer of a dog. ¶ 18. The “mere ownership” of a property where a dog resides is not enough to establish that the landowner is a harborer. Instead, a harborer must exert a certain amount of control over the premises where ethe dog is kept. A landowner’s ability to set rules is not sufficient. The “kind of premises control that counts is the control which was exercised by a person who was part of the same household as the dog.” ¶ 20. For example, a father who permits his adult daughter and her dog to live with him can be considered a harborer—but that is not the same level of control as a landowner who permits tenants to keep dogs.
Likewise, the condo association was not a keeper of the dog. Keeping a dog means exercising “care, custody or control over the dog.” ¶ 32. This analysis requires consideration of whether the person (or entity, in this case) had control over the dog itself—not just the property. An ability of a landlord to exclude dogs from the property does not amount to sufficient control to make them a keeper of the dog.
We see these issues arise again and again in our dog-bite cases. Were the dog and the dog’s owner actually living with this person at the time of the bite? Is the homeowner who rents out a single room a harborer? What if it is an attached mother-in-law suite? What about a landlord that said no dogs, but then knew his tenant was violating the rule? Does a dog owner and their dog need to be living in a home for a certain amount of time before the landowner becomes a harborer? These are the types of questions that matter most in Wisconsin dog-bite cases, and the answer often determines whether or not there is any insurance coverage available.





