Emily N. Bates

Based in the Hartford, WI office, Emily serves as the Lead Subrogation Paralegal, where she plays a key role in managing a broad spectrum of subrogation claims. In addition to her casework, she oversees the firm’s team of paralegals and claims specialists, ensuring smooth operations and consistent excellence across the board. Emily earned her Bachelor…

Sarah Holtz

Sarah Holtz is a Senior Paralegal based in the Hartford, Wisconsin office of Matthiesen, Wickert & Lehrer, S.C. A proud graduate of UW-Whitewater, she earned her Bachelor of Science in Political Science and Legal Studies in 2016. With over seven years of legal experience, Sarah has developed a strong foundation in insurance defense, litigation, and…

Crystal D. Pogorzelski

Crystal D. Pogorzelski is a Senior Paralegal based in the Hartford, Wisconsin office of Matthiesen, Wickert & Lehrer, S.C. Known for her dedication, precision, and depth of legal knowledge, Crystal plays a key role in supporting the firm’s attorneys and ensuring efficient, high-quality case management.

Julie A. May

Julie A. May is a Paralegal and Legal Assistant at the Hartford, Wisconsin office of Matthiesen, Wickert & Lehrer, S.C. Her work focuses on handling a variety of subrogation claims as well as assisting Associate Attorneys, Donald Henderson and Raven R. Jelinske. She received her Associates degree in Applied Sciences in Paralegal Studies from Rio…

Cindy L. Stys

Cindy L. Stys is a Paralegal in the Hartford, Wisconsin office at Matthiesen, Wickert & Lehrer, S.C. Her work focuses on handling a variety of subrogation claims, specifically ERISA. Cindy has 30 years of experience in Subrogation. She enjoys working closely with clients and negotiating settlements with various parties. This line of work has helped Cindy…

Meghan R. Koenig

Meghan R. Koenig is a File Intake Coordinator in the Hartford, WI office of Matthiesen, Wickert & Lehrer, S.C. Her day-to-day job duties revolve around data entry of new cases that are referred to the firm. She also assists at the reception desk and lends a helping hand around the office with things such as…

Lisa M. Liebenow

Lisa M. Liebenow is a Billing Clerk in the Hartford, WI office of Matthiesen, Wickert & Lehrer, S.C. Lisa joined the MWL team in 2022. She manages portions of billing in the accounting department and handles daily deposits for client payments.

Caitlin L. McGoohan

Caitlin L. McGoohan is the Receptionist in the Hartford, WI office of Matthiesen, Wickert & Lehrer, S.C. She also assists both Partner, Nancy A. Case and Associate Attorney, Christopher R. Vandeventer. Her day to day includes drafting letters and lending a helping hand to MWL’s branch offices and remote employees. She also works within the…

Amanda R. Peterson

Amanda R. Peterson is a Billing Clerk in the Hartford, WI office of Matthiesen, Wickert & Lehrer, S.C. As a motivated billing clerk, Amanda’s day-to-day duties include invoicing, billing and working one-on-one with clients and local counsel! In 2020, Amanda graduated from Moraine Park with high honors from the Accounting Program. She then joined the…