Nancy A. Case is an insurance litigation trial lawyer. Nancy’s practice areas include health insurance and ERISA litigation, insurance litigation, workers’ compensation, subrogation, and family law.

Nancy obtained her Bachelor of Arts degree in Literature and Communications from the University of North Florida, Jacksonville, Florida and her Juris Doctor from Chicago Kent College of Law, Chicago, Illinois. Prior to joining MWL, Nancy was with the law firm of Ogletree, Deakins, Nash, Smoak & Stewart, P.C. in Chicago, Illinois, with primary practice in subrogation and litigation for one of the largest multi-employer ERISA funds in Illinois.

Nancy is licensed in Wisconsin, Washington, and Illinois and is a member of the Illinois Trial Bar. Nancy also practices Family Law and has begun practicing in Sheboygan County, Wisconsin as Guardian Ad Litem representing children in need of protection and services. Nancy is also serving as President of the Sheboygan County Bar Association during its 2017/2018 term.

When Nancy isn’t litigating, drafting/revising ironclad subrogation provisions, or helping children and families in need, she spends time with her family and is often attending soccer, basketball, and baseball games, and this summer has added Junior Golf to the sports mix. Nancy is also actively involved with Kohler Schools having served as a School Board Member, Performing Arts Organization President, and currently a member with Kohler’s Soccer Club organization.


Chicago Kent College of Law, Chicago, Illinois, 2001, J.D.

  • Illinois Supreme Court Rule 711 Senior Law Student License 2010 and 2011 representing criminal felony suspects and defending felony criminal defendants as part of First Defense Legal Aid program.

University of North Florida, Jacksonville, Florida, 1991, B.A.

  • Major: Literature/Communications

Speaking Engagements

Improving Plan Subrogation Language, September 20, 2016, MWL webinar presented to the public.

ERISA Subrogation and Reimbursement, May 12, 2016, seminar presented to ARMSE Conference (Association of Railroad Medical Service Executives) in Gatlinburg, Tennessee. Co-Presenter: Ryan Woody.

Professional Associations & Memberships

  • American Bar Association
  • Illinois State Bar Association
  • Wisconsin State Bar
  • Sheboygan County Bar Association
  • Illinois Trial Bar
  • Property Loss Research Bureau (PLRB)
  • Liability Insurance Research Bureau (LIRB)
  • Claims Litigation Management (CLM)
  • National Association of Subrogation Professionals (NASP)

Comments are closed.